There are negative consequences for our students if we accept their errors in the belief that communication should take precedence over accuracy. Without feedback on errors, on the grounds that they have communicated despite these errors, then many students assume that what they said was correct and start to make these errors habitual.
There are negative consequences for our students if we accept their errors in the belief that communication should take precedence over accuracy. Up to a point, communication can take place with inaccurate language. ‘Street learners’, for example, do not need accurate language to get by: they supplement what they know of the language with pidginization, mime, and gesture.
However, if we don’t provide feedback to students on their errors, on the grounds that they have communicated despite these errors, then many students assume that what they said was the correct way of saying what they wanted to say, and they start to incorporate their errors into their mental model of the language. Once these errors become habitual—fossilised—then they are very difficult, if not impossible, to rectify. This explains the commonly observed phenomenon of students stuck at an intermediate level—with good vocabulary but flawed grammar—who are unable to progress because their habits are far too well established.

Reliable and continuous feedback ensures that students can reach the highest level if they choose to do so. Done in the moment, providing feedback sentence by sentence doesn’t take long. It gives students a chance to develop criteria for correctness, it challenges everyone and it builds secure foundations for the language. There is so much that can be learnt about the whole language from working properly on just one sentence!
We have time for this type of work in our classes because we don’t spend time on explanations, or ‘teacher talk’, or rote learning, or drills, or role plays, or gap filling exercises, or any of the usual textbook paraphernalia.
There may be a short term buzz for some from the ‘free practice’ part of the lesson commonly used in communicative classrooms, but is this the best use of students’ time with us? In the long run, just as in other fields such as playing a musical instrument or learning a trade, excellence comes from accuracy in what we do and how we do it; and fluency then comes from practice.