A mistake might just be a slip—even natives make mistakes sometimes—but it often tells us that a student hasn’t learned something, or hasn’t fully automated something yet. This is vital information for us. The energy to say something is there, and we know the student can’t yet quite say it correctly: the ground is fertile for them to learn. Importantly, everyone else in the class can learn something at the same time.
You don’t have to be the student who is working on a sentence to be learning and becoming aware of new things. You can become aware of some new feature of how the language works by watching others, just as much as you can when practising yourself.
That’s why a mistake really is a gift to the class: the mistake and its nature tell us precisely where the boundary lies between the known and the unknown for that student at that moment. And most often, others in the class will share that uncertainty, and will learn by observing. And if it’s something another student does already know thoroughly then their inner certainty will be deepened.
Very often we hear other students in the class suddenly saying “Aha!” as they observe the route a student follows to reach a solution. These “Aha!” moments are vivid and memorable, and they motivate students in the journey of turning themselves from beginners into near-native speakers.