Finger correction

Finger correction

A student says a sentence. There’s something to be worked on: a word is missing, there’s one too many words, or they are in the wrong order; the verb tense is wrong, or there’s a possible contraction; there’s a pronunciation problem.

Finger correction is one way to help the student to correct his sentence before he practises it. We hold up our hands with our fingers outstretched and get the student to say his sentence again. As he does so, we ‘place’ each word in order on a finger. So now everyone can ‘see’ the sentence and the student can start to work on the problem. Here’s Roslyn Young talking about this very powerful technique.

Finger correction - a simple example
Finger correction – a simple example

Sometimes just putting the words on the fingers is sufficient for the student to spot the problem and fix it himself. 

If the student needs more help, we have several options. We can point to a place in the sentence. We can point to the gap between fingers to show where a word is missing, or fold down a finger to show a word is not needed; we can cross two fingers to show that these words are in the wrong order; we can pull on the end of a finger to show that an ending is missing …

If the student still can’t fix the problem, we can call on others in the class to help, we can point on a wall chart to supply a missing element, we can create a new situation that sheds light on the problem, …

Once the problem has been solved, we usually get the student to practise saying the corrected sentence a few times to strengthen the trace of what he’s been working on. While he’s doing this, a student often needs to point on our outstretched fingers one by one to help him hold the sentence unchanged in his mind.

Why is finger correction such a powerful technique?

  • Having a sentence on our fingers, one finger for each word, gives the student something visual to ‘hold’ his sentence if he is finding it difficult to keep it stable in his mind.
  • We can be precise or vague in showing the student where the problems in his sentence are. (The more the student can fix things for himself, the better, and it’s only if we give him the chance to do so that we, and he, find out how much he can do without help.)
  • We can stay silent while showing him where he needs to work; and by using gestures, we can direct him to one or another part of his sentence.
  • By grouping our fingers in different ways, and changing the pace of our gestures, we can help him to chunk words properly and make his sentence flow.
  • Using our fingers means that everyone in the class can see what’s being worked on and can practise along with the student who happens to be the current focus of the class.
  • Using finger correction is, for the students, a halfway house between speaking and writing: neither completely ephemeral nor completely permanent. It helps the students to hold the sentence in their minds without it being written.
  • If they are holding the sentence in their mind they do more work on it than if it was written on the board, and thus it leaves a deeper ‘trace’ in the mind.
  • Working this way draws students’ attention to the linguistic form rather than the meaning of the sentence. It’s the linguistic forms the foreign language uses that need most work.

There are other ways of correcting sentences (for example, drawing a line for each word on the board) but using your fingers is convenient, economical, always available, and flexible. It’s a technique well worth mastering.

Here is a video showing how to use your fingers to ‘chunk’ a phrase: