1. Who’s supposed to be practising in a language class? So who should do most of the talking? The students? Or the teacher?
2. When you correct a word, phrase or sentence by simply saying it back to the class correctly, how are they to know exactly where the error was? Or what they should have done differently? All you’ve done is to give them the answer: what inner criteria have you helped them develop?
3. Since students’ listening to a foreign language is unreliable, why would you think listening to teacher speech would be a solid foundation for their learning?
4. The more you talk, the more you are part of a conversation with the class. Is that your role? Shouldn’t you be a coach or quality controller or source of feedback? Can you fulfil that role if you are also a participant?
5. Does copying the teacher usually (ever?) permit someone who couldn’t already do it, to make a French <r> or a Spanish <rr> or an English <r>?
6. We’re teaching people, not robots or copying machines. How will our students become independent of us if most of the time all we ask them to do is copy us?
7. The students’ ears might be unreliable, but yours aren’t. The less you talk, the more you’ll hear. Only you can provide the feedback students need if they are to learn to sound native. How will you provide that if you talk more than you listen?
8. Can you stop yourself? Once you start talking aren’t you likely to carry on? Add an explanation here, an aside there, a favourite anecdote or quotation … and all in the foreign language your students hardly know? Is that really what you are there for?
9. Watching a dancer or a skater or a musician might inspire you to take up these arts, but it won’t tell you where to put your feet, or how to balance your limbs or where to put your fingers. You can only learn these things by doing and finding out what happens. Isn’t it the same for any skill? So why should listening to speech tell us what to do with our breath, vocal cords, tongue, jaw, and lips?
10. There is an alternative: the students have to try, make mistakes, try again, and pay attention. And you the teacher have to give precise feedback and steer them towards native-like behaviour and then help them get enough practice. And you can do this silently, without giving them the answer, using mime, gesture, pointing, and facial expression etc.